On speech act disjunction

In this paper, we investigate disjunctions that combine an assertion with a question. We will explore a number of puzzles arising from such construction and propose an account which construes speech act disjunction as a device to introduce alternative discourse strategies.

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Who am I to (dis)agree? Interpretation sensitive agreement: Experimental evidence from French relatives

Agreement morphology is often assumed to realize φ-features unin- terpreted at LF. We provide experimental evidence from French relative clauses showing that agreement can in fact have an interpretative effect, adding to the range of ‘semantic agreement’ effects (e.g. Charnavel & Sportiche 2025). The choice of variable person agreement turns out to be sensitive to the placement of focus. We provide an analysis that relies on the interaction between focus, binding and the distribution of focus-sensitive operators.

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

A unified semantics for two temporal paradoxes

This paper discusses two naturally occurring temporal paradoxes, temporal metalepsis and time travel discourse, and argues that they can be predicted by the following hypothesis: events are not restricted to a single temporal location, and can be felicitously asserted to occur at different times. I further show that this hypothesis is independently motivated by the grammar, and claim that it is a natural extension of fundamental principles of event semantics: the treatment of events as paralleling prototypically spatial individuals.

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Combinatorial restrictions across lexical categories: CP and DP-complementation

Attitude verbs like know, believe, surprise, fear differ in their combinatorial restrictions, e.g. "Jo knows that/whether we won" vs. "Jo believes that/*whether we won". Previous work attributes such differences to semantic properties associated with these verbs. Results from emotive nominalizations present a challenge for such meaning-based explanations, and show that the combinatorial restrictions of attitude predicates arise in a complex interplay of semantic and morpho-syntactic factors.

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Wondering hopefully/fearfully: How do desires and inquisitive attitudes interact?

We describe a novel interpretive difference between x wonders hopefully ?p and x wonders fearfully ?p, where the former is only compatible with x hoping p, but the latter, with x either fearing p or not p. Extending a goal-based analysis of root polar questions by Tabatowski (2022) to embedding under inquisitive predicates, we argue that this difference arises due to hopefully imposing general constraints on an agent’s goals, in particular on their attitudes in entertaining questions, that fearfully does not.

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

The presuppositions of 'forget'

The propositional attitude verb forget has received relatively little attention in the formal linguistics literature, though its properties present interesting problems for formal semantics. White (2014) argues that a uniform account of forget as a factive verb is possible. On this view, forget presupposes the truth of its clausal argument (See also Kiparsky & Kiparsky (1970)). But in order to do so, he claims that a covert modal operator is obligatorily present in non-finite complements of forget, deriving modalized factive presuppositions. In this paper, I present data showing that the distribution of this covert modal operator is even more restricted. I argue that modalization of the ..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Agree to disagree: additive particles in responses

Most literature on too has focused on its "regular" uses, where, as a first approximation, too triggers a presupposition that one of the focus alternatives to its prejacent, distinct from the prejacent itself, is true (e.g., Axel likes cats. BROOK likes cats, too.). There has also been some discussion of "refutational too", used in positive polarity responses that refute the antecedent utterance (e.g., A: You didn't do your homework. B: I did too!). Recently, Thomas (2023) proposed that refutational too is a response particle, akin to yes and no—or even more pertinently, to French si and German doch. In this paper, I present novel data on what I will call "confirmatory too", which is used ..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Cross-linguistic variation in the lexical semantics of conjunction

A longstanding debate about conjunction concerns so-called ‘asymmetric’ interpretations with additional causal or temporal inferences. Some theories posit a semantic component of conjunction as part of their explanation (e.g. Gómez Txurruka 2003). In this paper, we explore an unstated prediction of such accounts: that the specific semantics of conjunction might vary (i) across languages, and (ii) across conjunction strategies within a language. Drawing on data from A’ingae (an indigenous language of Ecuador) and Gizey (an indigenous language of Cameroon and Chad) respectively, we show that both predictions are met, arguing that such semantic variation is constrained in ways anticipate..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Which alternatives matter? The role of the Question Under Discussion and speaker knowledge in conditionals

Conditional perfection (CP) is often analyzed as a quantity implicature that arises when “if p, q” is strengthened by excluding relevant alternatives to p. If this analysis is correct, CP should not arise in contexts that do not license exhaustification, such as when the Question Under Discussion (QUD) does not make alternative antecedents salient, or when the speaker cannot be assumed to know them. To date, experimental studies on CP have revealed limited or inconclusive evidence in support of these typical signatures of quantity implicatures. In two experiments, we demonstrate robust support for both signatures: Experiment 1 found that CP arose only when the conditional answered an ant..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Probabilistic non-maximality

In this paper, I present a probabilistic reconstruction of Križ’s (2015, 2016) account of non-maximal interpretation. The proposal addresses a general problem noted by Križ’s (2015: 85-6), which is shared by other QUD-based approaches to non-maximality (e.g. Bar-Lev 2021; Križ and Spector 2021): for these accounts to work, one needs to posit a fundamental disconnect between the question that is asked and the QUD that is addressed. This is problematic, especially in the absence of a non-stipulative method for identifying the QUD that is being addressed in a given context. In the proposed framework, the overt question alone determines the relevant QUD, allowing non-maximal interpretatio..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

The Japanese scalar particle hitotsu ‘even’: Variations of EVEN items

The Japanese classifier tsu is used for counting separable inanimate entities, and when combined with the numeral hito ‘one’, as in hito-tsu, it indicates that the number of entities is one. However, hitotsu can also function as a scalar particle, where hitotsu itself is interpreted as ‘even’. In this paper, I analyze the meaning and use of hitotsu as a scalar particle by comparing it with ordinary scalar particles, such as sae ‘even’, and show that the scalar particle hitotsu imposes a semantic restriction that the noun it attaches to must be non-specific and interpreted as the theme of an event. I argue that the scalar particle hitotsu is sensitive to event kinds and creates co..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

On aspectual coercion in before-clauses: Evidence from processing

Sentences with accomplishments in before-clauses are prima facie ambiguous between a strong reading and a weak reading, and two types of theories of these sentences have been proposed. Under-specification theories posit that the before-clauses in question are not actually ambiguous: their only LF corresponds to the weak reading, with the strong reading falling out as a subcase. Rett’s (2020) ambiguity theory, by contrast, claims that the strong reading surfaces by default, with the weak reading only arising if we coerce the embedded accomplishment into an achievement. Under standard psycholinguistic assumptions, coercion incurs a processing cost, and hence, I argue, Rett’s (2020) theory ..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

On the Universal Construal of Mandarin any

Mandarin polarity-sensitive item rènhé, just like English any, is ungrammatical under a necessity modal; nevertheless, this may be ameliorated by the presence of the quantificational adverb dou, with the rènhé-DP carrying a universal construal. Crucially, the presence of dou alone is not sufficient to render rènhé grammatical. We suggest that the distribution of Mandarin rènhé in a modal environment is best captured by the two-layered approach by Crniˇc (2019a,b, 2022), according to which i) the license of any is subject to Strawson downward entailment, and ii) exhaustification merely plays a supplementary role by creating an environment hospitable to any. Along with these lines, we..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Semantic micro-variation in distributivity marking in Highland Mayan Sign Language

There are several ways of overtly marking distributivity across languages. In this paper, we focus on three distributive constructions in Highland Mayan Sign Language (HMSL): ONE-smooth-arc, ONE-punctuated-arc, and ONE-alt. We show that HMSL patterns with other sign languages in making use of reduplication and space to mark distributivity in these constructions. However, we also observe micro-variation in the way these constructions are interpreted. Accordingly, we propose that the strategies observed thus far can be decomposed and that HMSL’s three distributive constructions are the result of the pluralizing of an allocation construction (‘x-FOR-i’) at different nodes. Our data furthe..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Set-anchored anaphora in Rioplatense Spanish: Direct object clitic doubling

This paper analyzes accusative clitic doubling in Rioplatense Spanish as an anaphoric device: the clitic presupposes a uniquely identifiable discourse set, and the doubled DP refers to or quantifies over it, rendering clitic doubling truth-conditionally superfluous. A DRT implementation models clitic doubling as a redundant update step and derives the attested distribution: licensing with regular definites (including kind- and collective-denoting nominals), exclusion with narrow-scope nominals, and clitic doubling of indefinites only under wide scope or proportional readings. Number and gender mismatches between the clitic and the doubled DP further indicate that clitics function as anaphori..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Free choice and dual prohibition in (non)monotonic contexts

This paper examines three prominent approaches to Free Choice (FC) and Dual Prohibition (DP): the implicature account relying on exhaustivity (EXH; Fox 2007; Bar-Lev & Fox 2017, 2020), the cognitive-bias account based on Neglect Zero (NZ; Aloni 2022), and a recent development of the implicature account grounded in presuppositional exhaustification (PEX; Bassi, Del Pinal & Sauerland 2021; Del Pinal, Bassi & Sauerland 2024). While all three approaches capture the FC-DP alternation in simple sentences (e.g., Leo can/cannot buy the cupcake or the pear), they diverge in their predictions regarding the strength of FC and DP in non-monotonic environments (e.g., Exactly one child can/can..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Quantifiers that are more monotone are easier to learn

Linguistic universals have been hypothesized to bound the observed properties of natural languages at all levels of linguistic analysis (Greenberg 1966; Croft 2003; van der Hulst 2008). In the domain of semantics, such universals are often explained by appeal to general information-theoretic and cognitive facts, from efficient communication to ease of learning. This paper expands the range of the ease of learning explanation through a case study of monotone quantifiers. While most existing studies compare expressions which either do or do not satisfy a given universal property, we here define a metric for measuring monotonicity in degrees. A computational experiment shows that this degree co..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

On the plurality of epistemic indefinites

This paper addresses a cross-linguistic puzzle about epistemic indefinites: determiners that are grammatical in episodic contexts and that trigger an ignorance inference. While their singular forms converge in yielding obligatory ignorance, their plural counterparts diverge in the presence or absence of obligatory ignorance readings and syntactic marking of plurality. I propose an account in team semantics with two independent parameters: (i) plurality in the domain and (ii) strict vs. lax assignment extension, together with a variation condition. The analysis derives three distinct types of plural EIs and explains the distribution of collective and non-collective readings, as well as the pr..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Neg-raising, accessibility and propositional anaphora

Neg-raising predicates show a special behavior with respect to propositional anaphora. When negated, a neg-raising predicate makes a discourse referent available for the negation of the proposition denoted by its embedded clause. Non-neg-raising predicates do not allow such anaphora. The behavior is puzzling since no constituent of the sentence denotes the negation of the embedded clause. I suggest that an excluded middle presupposition-based approach, cf. Bartsch 1973, to neg-raising offers a solution. I propose that one disjunct of the excluded middle presupposition introduces a discourse referent for the negation of the embedded clause. This discourse referent is accessible conditionally ..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Propositional anaphora and alternatives in the semantics of in which case

Recent decades have seen a wealth of research on appositive relative clauses. In this paper, we look at a closely related construction: parentheticals introduced by in which case (IWCs). We show that IWCs share many major properties with appositives, but also one major difference: they impose a requirement for epistemic alternatives to the content of their anchor. We develop a formal account of IWCs extending AnderBois, Brasoveanu & Henderson 2015’s formalism and show how together with a suitable alternative requirement, this derives their similarities and differences. Finally, we turn to examine the compositional source of this requirement, building on Moltmann 2021’s proposal for o..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Rethinking embeddability and context sensitivity inhonorification: evidence from Korean si

Argument and addressee honorification in many languages show an embeddability asymmetry, where only argument honorification can be embedded. This aligns with a generalization that content-oriented markers are embeddable while utterance-oriented markers are not (Portner, Pak & Zanuttini 2019). While Korean shows a parallel asymmetry in its argument and addressee honorification markers, it has a non-canonical use of the argument honorification marker si where it functions as an addressee honorification marker while still being embeddable. These findings challenge the association between utterance sensitivity and embeddability. In order to bridge this gap, we analyze si as a variable-introd..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Counterfactual interpretation as search for coherence in a learned model of the world

We propose a semantics for counterfactuals that explicitly connects it to cognitive models of temporal / causal inferences in narrative discourse comprehension. Both narrative discourses and counterfactuals are understood by (i) constructing temporally-indexed sequences of situation models – analog, vector-space representations of meaning grounded in our experience perceiving and understanding the world (our learned model of the world) – and then (ii) enriching these representations with temporal inferences through a temporal coherence-seeking process. The account builds on the model of narrative discourse comprehension in Frank et al. (2003), showing how we can use it to move beyond the..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

On the scope of indefinites and underspecification

Sentences with indefinites inside scope islands allow for truth-conditions that seemingly require the indefinite, when viewed as an existential quantifier, to take scope outside of the island. This phenomenon of exceptional scope has given rise to numerous theories. Novel data show that what is standardly taken to be an exceptional scope construal of the indefinite should be seen as syntactically and semantically parallel to its regular scope construal. Ambiguity approaches to the scope of indefinites are incompatible with this observation. Given their very weak semantics for exceptional scope construals, competing functional approaches could be made to be compatible with the observation. Th..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Degreeless intensification and scale structure: Evidence from Bardi

As identified by Beck et al. (2009), languages vary in whether they grammatically encode scales via degrees of type d. Previous literature has identified a number of constructions which are unavailable in “degreeless” languages. We propose an additional metric: the absence of selective intensifiers. We argue that since degreeless languages do not grammatically encode scales, lexical items like intensifiers cannot be sensitive to adjectival scale structure. We propose an account of intensification within a Delineation Semantics framework (Klein 1980) that permits intensification with both relative and absolute adjectives, while predicting the lack of attestations of scale-structure sensit..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Reanalyzing frustration: Event maximality and inertia in two O’dam frustratives

Frustrative particles modify a clause by conveying the non-realization of an associated expectation. The semantics of frustrativity are relatively understudied, complicated by variation in whether the relationship between the marked clause and the ‘target’ of frustration is lexically or only pragmatically specified. We contribute to the emerging picture by reporting on O’dam, which is typologically unusual in having two contrastive frustratives: t1i and t1ipup. Where most existing analyses treat frustratives as clausal markers of non-inertia, we argue that O’dam frustratives are also sensitive to event-based non-maximality. We propose a unified approach on which the differences are d..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

The semantic composition of event counting expressions within nominals in Mandarin Chinese

Event counting expressions like three times are often thought of as adverbial modifiers of a verbal projection. This study establishes and analyzes an apparently related but puzzling phenomenon in Mandarin Chinese whereby an event counting expression consisting of a numeral and an event classifier is introduced within a nominal syntactic argument to a verb, that also contains a thematic nominal. Closely examining the relevant interpretive properties, I show that such constituents are able to express counts of events independently of composition with the verb. Moreover, the phenomenon should be understood to reflect a close syntax-semantic parallelism between event classifiers and individual ..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Outlook markers (as abstract discourse markers): An analysis of nanka in Japanese

We propose a formal model for dealing with what we call outlook markers, a subtype of discourse markers that govern discourse management pertaining to negotiations about ‘agreeable outlooks’ (on possibly subjective matters). For this purpose, we take up the semantic analysis of an ‘emphatic’ discourse marker nanka in Japanese. We argue that nanka is essentially a counterstance marker in that it imposes a constraint on the prior discourse that a contextually salient ‘counterstance’ is at issue, and that the speaker’s own stance embodied in the prejacent is incongruent with this counterstance as a subjective judgment. The model we develop combines Coppock’s (2018) outlook-based..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Redundancy and presuppositional exhaustification

Recent work has argued that different inferences, such as homogeneity and implicatures, are in fact presuppositions, based on similarities in their pragmatic status and their projection properties (Fox, 2018; Bassi et al., 2021 a.o.). Nevertheless, these inferences seem to differ from presuppositions in some ways: (i) as evidenced by the Hey, wait a minute! test, homogeneity and implicatures don’t interact with the common ground in the same way as presuppositions (Spector, 2013; Bassi et al., 2021) and (ii) homogeneity and implicatures project differently from presuppositions in some environments, like the scope of certain quantifiers (Spector, 2013; Križ, 2015; Chatain and Schlenker, 202..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory

Incremental interpretation of discourse coherence: Evidence from reading times

In some discourses, a given inference would be natural at one point, but impossible at the next. We focus here on such cases with inferences of temporal and causal order usually described as ambiguities of discourse coherence. The fact that these inferences come and go over the course of a discourse raises challenges for their representation within theories of dynamic semantics: representations must either include coherence-related meaning in a way that can be selectively edited later, or else persistently underspecify it. As theories of humans' actual cognitive states, these approaches make different predictions for patterns of difficulty during real-time comprehension. Borrowing a standard..

Semantics and Linguistic Theory